Kevin B. Fagan, PhD – The Recalcitrant Legionary: Part II

By Kevin B. Fagan, PhD


Despite the ‘no friendship’ rule and prompt obedience, Legionaries’ paths sometimes cross, allowing spontaneous friendships to grow through the cement.

Fr. James’ Legionary priestly ministry, his various assignments and how they were made, false accusations and misunderstandings, his path criss-crossing with the author.


Busy in Santiago

After ordination, Manus returned to Ireland and then traveled to Mexico. While in Dublin, he recruited Declan Creighton to the Congregation. Hence the request he mentioned to me in an email last Jan. 30th, 2005:

I told Fr. Cardenas by phone personally and directly that I needed another priest with me for two reasons: to keep me company, and to take over my work at least until September; but the only priest I could accept was Fr. Declan; all the others would cause me stress, etc. This was on the 27th Dec. and I’m still waiting for a reply. Typical.

All the brethren too busy in Santiago, was the delayed reply from Rev. Jose Cordenas, legionary authority in Chile, through his envoy Rev. Danal O?Keefe, lc, who had previously spent 20 minutes visiting the sick priest. One positive outcome is that at least Fr. Declan preached movingly at Manus’ funeral. In Monterrey, Mexico, Manus witnessed the enormous amount of money transferred from legionary schools to General Headquarters in Rome, and the falsehood of theft accusations against Pedro Martin, former school principal.

Broken Promises

Manus soon saw where some of this money went. Absolutely shocked and scandalized is how he described his reaction upon later meeting Maciel living the life of a king at the most luxurious hotel in Valencia, Spain.

There, at the Cumbres (= Highlands) School in Valencia our roads crossed again. After six years of blind obedience on vocational work in Chile, I was rewarded with the position of principal of that school, switching with Manus who was to go to Concepción, Chile. With typical legionary trickery, Manus was informed, not in Valencia but during a family visit to Ireland, about his change. In Ireland, his instructions were to go to Rome to see Rev. Maciel; upon his arrival there he was informed that God wanted him to go urgently to Chile. However, by then, Manus didn?t believe in the same god as Maciel, and, without arguing, simply went back to Spain to pack his bags. In Valencia, he gave me the inside story on how the school was founded and developed. The main problem was the Rev. Alfredo Torres, who had broken promise after promise to parents and teachers, above all, about its co-ed features and administration, leaving Manus to lead the school and face the disgruntled parents. Once more, this is an example of a typical legionary tactics: one member giving orders and another being left to face the public [music]. Manus suggested I request Fr. David Owen as spiritual mentor in Valencia. A former principal of a similar school and situation in Madrid, the Everest, Owen knew how to handle Torres. I daily pray for dear David, wherever he may be, for the kindness and patience he often shared as we strolled the Cumbres patios and Mediterranean sands.

A Good-looking Secretary

Meanwhile, Manus and I promised to stay in touch. I suggested he concentrate on Concepcion in Chile, a colonial city by the sea, where previously I had been favorably received by the archbishop, Mons. Fernando Moreno. Little did I know that such was Divine Providence for Manus to achieve pastoral happiness and independent living during his final years. After some time in Valencia, a new arrival in the form of Rev. Bernardo Skertchley, former personal secretary to Rev. Maciel, arrived. On my commenting on certain pathetic behavior on his part, Manus remarked, have you not noticed how all Maciel?s secretaries are good-looking blondes? Only years later did I understand the meaning of that rhetorical question.

Conscience and Cardinals

As agreed, we remained in contact and continued communicating. Manus gradually opened doors in Concepcion, dedicating himself to youth ministry in high schools and colleges, as I was moving out of the Legion into the diocesan clergy at Ft. Worth, Texas. I was content to mail him books for his library and supplies for his new chapel, San Patricio. Both of us were happy to see Rev. John O?Brien leave the Legion and return to priestly ministry in his hometown of Port Laoise, Ireland.
So, it was no wonder that Manus wanted to book his flight to Dublin in 1997, passing through Dallas, Texas. I?d like to share stories and compare notes, he insisted. I also was interested in his view of my doctoral dissertation on freedom of conscience in Cardinal Newman, inspired by my experience of its absence in the Legion. I had also spoken with Cardinal Arinze about papal approval of the seemingly non-canonical Legion Constitutions. I drove down from my parish on the prairie in my old Oldsmobile, dressed in shorts and Texan hat, a most un-legionary outfit. After pick-up at DFW airport, I considered the cafeteria at the University of Dallas, a Catholic university for independent thinkers, an appropriate venue for our fraternal get-together.

Reform or Collapse?

I was overjoyed at his success story in Concepcion. Well, I thought to myself, I?d been the legionary founder there, and who better than Manus to fit the position? Manus wanted to know about my experience in a diocese. A totally different life-style, I confessed. Stay where you are, I suggested. We?re not trained to be parish administrators in a new environment, though both agreed we should have left the Legion years ago. In my analysis about freedom of conscience with the Legionaries, I asked him whether the Congregation could be reformed from within to come in line with Catholic Vatican II teaching and canonical law: allowing freedom of choice of spiritual directors, freedom of conscience to leave the group, and freedom of communication with local bishops. Manus answered: if you take one brick from the totalitarian wall, the whole cult-like edifice collapses. One of my last memories within the Congregation was a lunch with former Archbishop Daniel A. Cronin of Hartford, CT. I guess His Grace, like so many Church dignitaries, hardly dreamt his visit to the LC house at Cheshire, CT, was orchestrated to the last detail with only a few hand picked members allowed speak with him. Cardinal Arinze, on the other hand, had told me that the Pope never personally approves any constitutions and much less those with non-canonical elements.

A Missing Photo

On a personal note, Manus wanted the advice of a canon lawyer, who was also a religious. I was happy to pass on details of one I knew well and who understood Machiavellian methods. There and then, we called the lawyer on my cell phone. Later, Manus wanted to share notes, or rather two letters from Rev. Maciel, one typed, the other hand-written. The first told Manus to leave Concepción and go back to Legion community life in Santiago. The second, handwritten, said the Archbishop of Valencia, Spain, received a complaint that Manus had intimate relations with a female teenage student while acting as school principal. Maciel purported that he had photos of the event. Manus then recalled photos of himself in a bathing suit disappearing from his room at the minor seminary in Moncada, Valencia, no doubt performed during secret room inspection by the local legionary boss, Rev. Salvador Gomez. However, the fact of the two letters coming together felt suspicious to Manus. I also had knowledge of the same scare-tactic used with Paul Lennon and another Legionary priest. So, we decided to check out the story. Luck would have it that I personally knew the alleged victim and her parents, since I had been Manus? successor in that position. Manus called the Chancery office of the Archbishop and I contacted the parents. We found no information in that regard, no corroborating evidence. The story was patently false, concocted by… Weeks later Maciel phoned Manus at 2 a.m. one night, out of the blue, to explain there had been some misunderstanding [un malentendido]in his previous information.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s